1 — Discovery and product surfaces
We test the public, logged-out surfaces of every platform first — homepage, directory, AI landing pages, companion catalogs. Then we evaluate the logged-in product where it materially changes the experience.
Every site in this round-up is graded by the same rubric. The six pillars below roll up into one weighted verdict score on a 0–10 scale.
We test the public, logged-out surfaces of every platform first — homepage, directory, AI landing pages, companion catalogs. Then we evaluate the logged-in product where it materially changes the experience.
Each platform is graded across content library, models directory, AI generation, AI companions, UX & mobile, and privacy & account. Pillar scores are 0–10. Platforms that do not ship a category get a 0 in it — covering a category is a feature.
Content library and AI generation carry 20% each. Models directory, AI companions, UX, and privacy carry 15% each. The result is a single weighted 0–10 verdict you can sort on.
We make no legal, consent, or safety guarantees on behalf of any platform — we describe what the product does, and we name claims that need user verification. Adult AI tooling reviews include responsible-use callouts.